Summary
I ’m on gameboard for Greta Gerwig’sChronicles of Narniamovies , thoughthere are some recent Netflix franchises that raise business about how the adaptation could be handled . I was the complete long time for Disney ’s Narnia adaptations upon their release in the 2000s , and I ’ll always entertain some consideration for them as fun , light - hearted fancy movies . However , I finger like it ’s fair to admit that they ’re not as definitive of adaptations as Peter Jackson’sLord of the Ringstrilogy or theHarry Potterseries , which arrived around the same time . That opens the door forGreta Gerwig ’s Narnia movies .
Greta Gerwig has try that she ’s equal to of making aesthetic film that feel fresh and veritable while also remain mostly accessible and easygoing to consume . It stimulate me to imagine what she ’ll do with Narnia ifshe can bring the visual brilliance ofBarbie , the cozy cottage warmth ofLittle Women , and deliver a story that ’s faithful to C.S. Lewis ’s novels . Netflix has the chance to educate the classic cinematic rendition of one of thebest tiddler ’s illusion book series , enclose the classic saga to a generation of novel audience . Still , there are some decisive pitfalls they need to debar .
The Witcher Has Given Netflix A Bad Reputation For Adapting Fantasy
The Witcher Has Received Criticism For Deviating From Source Material
Cast
Game of Throneschanged the television aspect , make a wave where every streaming military service want to replicate its success with a TV drama found on a notable phantasy series . Prime Video has tried its hand withThe Wheel of TimeandRings of Power , Apple TV+ hadSee , andNetflix ’s television cataloghas expanded with a variety of fantasy adaption likeShadow & Bone , Avatar : The Last Airbender , One Piece , and many more . My nidus here is onThe Witcher , as it ’s been arguably the most scrutinized fantasy series they ’ve had , and it ’s based on novel .
Even when the series was well - reexamine , The Witchernever really sat well with me , mostly due to my issue with the show ’s visual aesthetic . However , the main criticism of the illusion drama has been its deviation from the source material , even to the point where The Witcher book author Andrzej Sapkowski spoke in an audience with the YouTube channelCerealkillerz , saying,“I gave them some musical theme , but they never listened to me,“referring to the showrunners .
Alienating book reader and lover of the source material is the flying path to crushing an version ’s potential drop . While Netflix still has a massive reader base and pot of hits , there ’s plenty of dashing hopes circumvent show likeThe WitcherandAvatar : The Last Airbenderfrom viewers who ’d hoped for a more faithful interpretation .
Custom image by Milica Djordjevic
Rebel Moon Was Netflix’s Attempt At A Big-Budget Sci-Fi/Fantasy Movie Franchise
Rebel Moon’s Release Format Wasn’t Zack Snyder’s Full Vision
Rebel MoonandThe Chronicles of Narniaare vastly different stories , but there are some renowned flaws in the late sci - fi dealership ’s distribution that I see as important . enjoy him or detest him , Zack Snyder is an auteur movie maker who can bring a distinct trend to his projects , but the version ofRebel Moonthat have been free are n’t his cutting . Netflix desire to broaden the audience with PG-13 , reduce 2 - hour movies , with his director ’s emasculated R - rated versions discharge at a later date ( viaTHR ) . The unfreeze PG-13Rebel Moonmovies have 21 % and 15 % scores on Rotten Tomatoes .
they conformed their passing to standard 2 - hour movies , trim the grownup aspects that could ’ve made the films unique
The issue I see here is that Netflix brought on an auteur filmmaker to develop a sci - fi franchise that could potentially fracture the mold , put up something different toStar Wars . or else of croak through with it , they conformed their releases to standard 2 - 60 minutes movies , trimming the grownup vista that could ’ve made the cinema unequaled . I’m not a immense Zack Snyder fan , but I ’d much rather have seen his version upon going rather than the dilapidated PG13 cutsthat’ve already do away with any stake I had in the franchise .
How Greta Gerwig’s Narnia Movies Can Learn From These Franchises
Greta Gerwig Needs Full Creative Control & A Script That’s Faithful To C.S. Lewis’s Books
Hopefully , give the tremendous commercial success ofBarbie , Greta Gerwig will have last undercut on the interpretation ofChronicles of Narniathat ’s give out on the cyclosis serve . Bringing a massively popular seer filmmaker on for such a project only weigh when their leadership and artistic expertise is trusted in full . Personally , I ca n’t expect for Greta Gerwig’sChronicles of Narniafilms , and I think they have the potential to be all - clock time great phantasy movies .
source : THR , Cerealkillerz
